Christopher Mollard — founder of J4G Design, a Fulham design studio with twenty years of design experience.
Last updated 17 Nov 2026
In classic search, a customer types a few words into Google, scans a list of results, clicks through to several websites, compares them and then enquires with the one that feels right, whereas with an AI assistant they ask a full question, receive a short-list or a single recommendation, and usually arrive at your website already leaning towards you. That difference is the heart of the AEO vs SEO conversation, and it is why I think of the two as partners rather than rivals, because one gets you into the comparison and the other gets you into the answer, and most of your customers now move between both before they pick up the phone.
I have written about what AEO is and how it builds on SEO separately, so this post follows the journey itself, from the moment someone starts looking to the moment they become a customer.
What does the journey from a Google search to a sale look like?
The traditional route is one most of us know from our own habits. Someone searches a short phrase such as “kitchen fitter Fulham” or “brand designer London”, Google shows a page of results with a map pack and perhaps a few ads at the top, and the searcher opens three or four tabs so they can compare. They look at past work, read a few reviews and check whether the website is easy to use, before making a shortlist of their own and sending an enquiry or two.
What that means for your business is that ranking is only the first step, because once you are on the page you are competing side by side with everyone else who ranks, and the sale is won or lost on the website itself. This is where good SEO has always overlapped with good design and good copy, since a strong position brings people to the door, but the case studies, the reviews and the clarity of the next step are what persuade them to come in.
How does an AI assistant change the route from search to sale?
When someone asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity or Google’s AI Mode for help, they tend to write the way they would speak to a friend, so instead of three keywords you get a whole situation, something like “I run a small building company in West London and my website looks dated, who could help with a new site and getting found locally?” The assistant reads around the web on their behalf, weighs up what it finds, and replies with a handful of names or sometimes just one, along with a short explanation of why each might suit.
So much of the comparing that used to happen across open tabs has already been done by the time the person reaches your website, which is why visits from AI assistants often feel different. The person has usually been told something specific about you, they arrive with a clearer idea of what they want, and when they do enquire the conversation tends to start further along, because they are checking that you are who the assistant said you were rather than starting their search from scratch.
AEO vs SEO: what is actually different about the two?
SEO, search engine optimisation, is the work of earning a strong position in Google’s list of results for the searches your customers make, through a well-built site, useful content, a healthy Google Business Profile and links from other trustworthy sites. AEO, answer engine optimisation, is the work of making sure that when an AI tool assembles an answer, your business is one of the sources it trusts enough to mention or cite. You will also see it called GEO, generative engine optimisation, and the “geo vs seo” and “seo vs aeo” debates are really the same conversation under different names.
The difference shows up in what each one rewards. Google’s rankings lean heavily on relevance, authority and the experience of the page, whereas AI assistants lean on how easily they can understand who you are, what you do and what evidence backs it up, which favours clear answers, question-shaped headings, structured data, and consistent mentions of your business on other sites. Much of the groundwork is shared, though, which is the part that tends to get lost when the two are framed as a choice.
Why do the two journeys need each other?
AI assistants do not invent their recommendations, they draw on what they can find, and a great deal of what they find is the same material that ranks well in Google, so a site that has been looked after for SEO is already giving the assistants something to work with. ChatGPT’s search, for example, leans on Bing’s index, and Google’s own AI Overviews sit on top of its ordinary results, which means a business that is invisible in classic search usually struggles to appear in AI answers too.
It works the other way as well. Customers rarely use just one route, so someone might hear about you from an assistant, then search your name on Google to see your reviews and your Business Profile before they get in touch, or start with a Google search and then ask an assistant to compare the two or three businesses they found. If either half of that journey is weak, the person can drift away at exactly the point they were about to choose you, which is why I build the two together for the businesses we work with rather than treating AI search as a separate project.
What have we seen on our own website?
I watch this closely on the J4G site because it is the easiest place to test what I recommend to clients. Visits to our website from ChatGPT roughly tripled between September and October 2026, from eleven sessions to thirty-five in Google Analytics, which is still a small number but a clear direction, and what struck me most was where those visitors landed, because most of them went straight to our case studies rather than the homepage.
That tells me two things that I think apply to most small businesses. The assistants are pointing people to evidence, so pages that show specific work for specific clients in specific places are doing a lot of the persuading, and the visitors arriving that way are already in the comparing-the-proof stage of their decision. Our case study on brand, website, SEO and AEO for a Fulham building company is a good example of the kind of page that can serve both journeys at once.
Where should a small business start?
For most of the businesses I speak to, the most sensible starting point is the shared foundation, because it pays off in both places at once. That usually means a fast, well-structured website, service pages that answer the questions customers actually ask, a Google Business Profile that is complete and kept fresh with reviews and posts, and case studies that describe the problem, the place and the outcome in plain language.
From there, the AEO layer adds the things that help an assistant understand and trust you, such as schema markup, an llms.txt file, making sure AI crawlers are not accidentally blocked, and building consistent mentions of your business around the web, while the SEO layer keeps building rankings through content and links. If you are curious how to tell whether any of it is working, I have written about how to judge whether your SEO is working, and the same thinking now extends to tracking visits and mentions from AI assistants.
Frequently asked questions
Is AEO replacing SEO?
No, and I would be wary of anyone who suggests it is. AI assistants rely heavily on the same pages and signals that rank in Google, so AEO builds on top of SEO rather than taking its place, and most customers still use both routes before they buy.
What is the difference between GEO and AEO?
They are two names for broadly the same idea, which is helping your business appear in answers generated by AI tools. GEO stands for generative engine optimisation and AEO for answer engine optimisation, and you will see both used for the same kind of work.
Are enquiries from AI assistants better than enquiries from Google?
They are often warmer, because the assistant has already done some of the comparing and the person arrives with a clearer idea of why they chose you. That said, Google still brings a much larger volume of visits for most small businesses, so the two complement each other rather than one being better.
How long does it take to show up in AI answers?
It depends on how established your site and reputation already are, so businesses with solid SEO foundations tend to start appearing sooner, and the structural AEO changes themselves can be made fairly quickly.
Would it help to talk it through?
If you are wondering how your business shows up across both routes, whether that is in Google’s results or in the answers people are getting from ChatGPT and its cousins, I am always happy to take a look and tell you what I see. You can find out more about our AEO service and how it sits alongside our SEO service, and when you are ready, drop me a line and we can have an unhurried conversation about where your own customers are coming from.